Cupcakes are in this season. Did you know? It’s no wonder, since these handheld cakes are the perfect way for a pastry chef to distinguish baking talents and decorative abilities to as many people as possible—in as cute a package as possible. And judging by the proliferation of cupcakeries around Austin in recent years, folks around this town are ready for more of this trendy treat.
We decided that a true test of a cupcakery’s mettle would be its vanilla cupcake. After all, any culinary whiz can whip together a fancy batch of baked goods. All you need are a dozen oddly complimentary ingredients and the guts to call it your own. But to truly see who has an appreciation for the Art of the Cupcake, what better test than the most forgettable plain-Jane flavor: vanilla?
ROUND ONE: Delish Mexican Vanilla Cupcake
Delish is where deliciousness goes to dine after dinner downtown. Located at 209 W 3rd St, this little boutique cupcake bakery manages three things really well: sweet, chic, and cute. Look for the yellow cube-shaped sign out front—although as soon as you walk in, you will be greeted by a gigantic oil painting of a cupcake in a yellow so vivid you can practically taste the hue. Delish is likely to have something new every time you visit, with daily special offerings, seasonal specials like a Father’s Day “Dr. Pepper Bourbon” cupcake, and twice-monthly “Pooches and Pupcakes” with free petite pupcakes for your canine compadre.
Delish took a classy stance on the old standby flavor of vanilla, using Mexican vanilla in the cake itself and in the buttercream topping. The frosting had been piped onto the little delicacy with care, and topped with a little nugget of sugary goodness. Beneath the wrapper, the cake was pale in hue, a soft creamy tan color. The consistency of the cake was light, fluffy, and not too crumbly. The frosting also left very little film in my mouth, as frosting sometimes has a tendency to do. The vanilla flavor was present but not overpowering. In short, this was a delicious and elegant cupcake with character.
(Laurel: Okay, this was a damn good cupcake! I am more of a vanilla than chocolate fan so it already had my attention and then the deliciously strong vanilla flavor contrasting the lightness of the cake, made it an instant favorite! I give this cupcake 4.5 out of 5 bites!)
We also sampled their daily special, the “PB Honey Banana Cupcake” which their menu described as “Banana Cake with a Peanut Butter Honey Buttercream, a drizzle of honey and a small piece of honeycomb.” I enjoyed the honey flavors but thought the peanut butter overpowered the taste of banana. (Laurel: Wait, there was banana in the cake? I thought it was peanut butter with a side of peanut butter!) The crystalline honeycomb topper was a graceful touch, and I give them props for attention to detail. (Laurel: I, fortunately, did not give her a chance to try the honeycomb. But let me tell you, it was delicious!)
ROUND TWO: Polkadots’ Vanilla Vanilla Cupcake
If your grandmother were to develop an obsession with handheld cakes, then Polkadots’ Cupcake Factory might be the sort of place she would feel right at home. (Laurel: More like Hansel and Gretel’s sugar haven! I’m surprised we didn’t see a trail of breadcrumbs leading up the front steps.) Although the pastel pink interior of the house-turned-bakery feels tiny enough to fit inside a muffin baking tin, the space has large windows to let in plenty of light and a wraparound patio to provide extra seating. Located at 2826 Rio Grande St, Polkadots bakes wedding cakes and offers twelve varieties of cupcakes daily for West Campus college students and pretty much anyone with a sweet tooth. They serve five daily flavors and seven rotating daily specials like “Strawberry Coconut” or “The Fluffernutter”.
The Polkadots style appears to be colorful, cute, and syrupy-sweet. Our Vanilla Vanilla cupcake looked almost distressingly cheerful with its golden yellow cake, soft-as-a-cloud American buttercream icing, all topped with eye-popping sprinkles in every color of the rainbow. If this style of icing is your thing, Polkadots may very well might be the right place for you—but personally, I found that even though it was creamy and well-made, the American buttercream icing was too insubstantial on the tongue. It was like the cotton candy of cake toppings. (Laurel: I really did love the icing on this one. Light. Fluffy. Not overwhelming. But the mexican vanilla in the Delish cupcake still had my attention. This was a close second place. I give this cupcake 4 out of 5 bites!)
To be fair we decided to try one of their daily specials as well, their “Black Bottom Cupcake” featuring chocolate cake topped with chocolate chip buttercream icing. If that wasn’t enough, they also included a center of cream cheese and chocolate chip icing. Now, perhaps by this point we had simply sampled too many cupcakes, but we were overwhelmed by this dense creation. I preferred the Black Bottom icing to that which topped the Vanilla Vanilla, but the center filling made the entire thing less stable and more apt to crumble in the hand. Good for a chocoholic, though. (Laurel: This cupcake is what put me into a food coma for the rest of the night… well, that combined with all the paint in bright colors on the windows. For a while there as I slipped into my cupcake coma, I wondered. Is this where unicorns go to die? And hey, speaking of which, what did they do to Hansel and Gretel?! But back to the Black Bottom cupcake. I know that if you are a chocoholic out there, this is YOUR cupcake!)
AND THE WINNER IS…
Delish Cupcakes wins this food fight for delivering a classy and original gourmet cupcake while still paying homage to the time-honored vanilla flavor. Congratulations to Delish!






















